Publicity Rockstar™ Method · Cheat Sheet

Your Podcast Pitching Reminder

Everything that matters, on one page. Keep this open when you build your list, write your pitch, and follow up. Your job is simple: make it as easy as possible for a host to say yes.

Golden Rules

To get a yes, every pitch must…

The 6 Steps

1
The Foundation

Rockstar Offer

🎯

Get clear on your audience, your expertise, and why podcasting matters for you right now. Podcasting only amplifies what already exists, so set this first.

2
Your Podcast List

The Audience

📋

Build a small, intentional list based on audience fit, host authority, and topic relevance, not size. One aligned show beats ten random ones.

3
Host's Attention

The Hit

💥

Shape 3–5 core speaking topics that are audience-first, solve a real problem, and feel relevant now. Reuse them across shows.

4
Write & Send

The Stage

Send a personal, manual pitch that answers fast: why this topic fits, why the audience cares, why you're credible. It's a relevance email, not a sales email.

5
Show Up

The Performance

🎤

Be prepared, not scripted. Listen more than you perform, speak in stories, and stay human. Your presence is part of your positioning.

6
Leverage It

The Promotion

📣

Do PR on your PR. Promote every episode, repurpose it into content, add it to your media page, and reference it in future pitches. It compounds.

Build Your List & Topics

🔍 Find the right shows

  1. Search your ideal podcast in iTunes, use "You might also like"
  2. Check the media & PR pages of others in your niche
  3. Google top-ranked lists (e.g. "top 100 leadership podcasts 2026")
  4. Use Listen Notes to search by keyword, audience, or competitor
Reactive extras: Matchmaker.fm and Podmatch, but only a tiny fraction of the 3.5 million shows are there, so lead with proactive research. Quality over quantity, always.

🎤 A strong topic has

  1. A clear outcome (what the listener walks away with)
  2. A clear audience (who it's really for)
  3. A clear angle (your fresh point of view)
Avoid: broad titles, vague transformation promises, and overused buzzwords. Keep 3–5 core topics, use them repeatedly, refine over time. Stories aren't just entertainment, they're evidence.

Anatomy of a High-Converting Pitch

1
Subject line – specific & relevant
2
Greeting – double-check the name before sending
3
Relate to the host – show you know the show
4
Introduce yourself – who you are & why relevant
5
Proof you're credible – short, clean, real
6
2–3 topic ideas – link to past interviews
7
No-pressure sign-off
8
Optional PS or a personal Loom video

Follow-Up = Professional Persistence

Send
Manually. No automation. Track everything you send.
+7 days
First follow-up if you hear nothing.
+4 weeks
Second follow-up. Bigger show = more follow-ups.
Silence is not rejection – it usually just means busy. After the interview, send a thank-you within 24 hours, confirm the publish date, add it to your tracker, and offer to help promote.

Track What's Happening

📧

Sign up for MailSuite

Get the paid version (about $10/month) at mailsuite.com. If the host hasn't opened your email, your subject line wasn't strong enough – resend the same pitch with a new subject line a few days later. If they opened it but didn't reply, follow up.

What To Do Now

Your next moves

Set it up once, then pitch every week

1
Create one Google Workspace folder with your pitch template, speaking topics, podcast list, and tracking sheet.
2
Sign up for MailSuite so you can see who opens your pitches.
3
Finalise your 3–5 core topics and your short credibility proof.
4
Build your first small list of aligned shows and research them.
5
Send your first batch of personal pitches, then log each one.
6
Follow up on schedule: +7 days, then +4 weeks.
The consistency habit: block 2 hours every week, the same day each week, to pitch and follow up. That rhythm is what turns podcasting into a predictable, repeatable authority system.
Publicity Rockstar™ Method · Podcast Pitching Cheat Sheet